OPEN ACCESS S

Al-Qamar

ISSN (Online): 2664-4398

ISSN (Print): 2664-438X

www.alqamarjournal.com

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times:

A Special Study of Pakistani Society

Dr. Nabeela Falak

Associate professor, Department of Islamic studies, The university of

Lahore Sargodha campus

Email: nabeelafalak@gmail.com

Abstract

Few topics generate as much controversy in contemporary Muslim

societies as the question of women's roles. Pakistan, a country

grappling with modernization, Islamization, economic development,

and democratic transition, offers a particularly revealing case. This

study examines the changing role of women in contemporary Pakistani

society through an interdisciplinary lens that takes Islamic teachings

seriously while engaging with empirical data, legal analysis,

sociological research, and policy evaluation. Moving beyond both

Western feminist critiques that dismiss Islam as inherently patriarchal

and conservative narratives that resist any change as un-Islamic, the

paper develops an internally grounded framework that distinguishes

between eternal ethical principles and historically contingent

interpretations. Drawing on Qur'anic exegesis, Hadith analysis,

classical legal theory, contemporary Islamic scholarship, Pakistani

legislation, development reports, and peer-reviewed research, the study

examines women's participation across education, professional

employment, family structures, public institutions, and political

leadership. It identifies persistent challenges: legal gaps between

constitutional guarantees and personal status laws, educational

disparities, occupational segregation, the double burden of paid work

and domestic labor, violence against women, and restrictive social

norms. The paper then develops an Islamic evaluation of

contemporary changes, arguing that the Qur'an's egalitarian ethic

127

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

supports women's full participation in all domains, but within a

framework that preserves family cohesion, modesty, and mutual

respect. The proposed model—family-centered empowerment with

ethical participation—rejects both Western individualistic feminism

and conservative patriarchal restriction, offering instead a distinctly

Islamic vision of women's development that is both faithful to sacred

texts and responsive to contemporary Pakistani realities.

Keywords: Women in Islam, Pakistani Society, Gender Roles,

Women's

Empowerment,

Family-Centered

Development,

Professional Women, Working Mothers, Legal Reform, Social

Change, Contemporary Pakistan

Introduction

Background of the Study

Pakistan stands at a crossroads. Since its founding in 1947, the country has

oscillated between competing visions of women's place in society. The

modernist vision of Muhammad Ali Jinnah emphasized women's full

participation in national development. The Islamization policies of the Zia-ul-

Haq era (1977-1988) restricted women's mobility and legal rights. Subsequent

decades have witnessed contradictory trends: the election of a woman Prime

Minister, Benazir Bhutto, alongside the rise of militant groups opposing girls'

education; the passage of landmark legislation against sexual harassment and

anti-women practices, alongside continued honor killings and forced marriages;

dramatic increases in girls' enrollment in schools and universities, alongside one

of the world's lowest female labor force participation rates.

The puzzle of Pakistani women's status is that formal indicators of

empowerment have improved significantly over the past three decades, yet

substantive equality remains elusive. More girls are in school than ever before,

but most remain at home after marriage. More women work outside the home,

but occupational segregation and wage gaps persist. More women participate

in politics (reserved seats ensure this), but their substantive influence remains

limited. More laws protecting women have been passed, but implementation is

weak and social norms resistant.

This gap between formal and substantive change requires explanation. Part of

the answer lies in the contested interpretation of Islamic teachings.

128

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

Conservative interpretations, often presented as the only authentic Islamic

position, have been used to justify restrictions on women's education,

employment, mobility, and public participation. Liberal interpretations,

dismissed as Westernized, have struggled to gain traction in a society where

religious authority remains largely in conservative hands. This study seeks to

move beyond this polarized discourse by developing an internally grounded

Islamic framework that takes sacred texts seriously, engages with contemporary

Pakistani realities, and offers practical guidance for policy and practice.

Problem Statement

The central problem this research addresses is the gap between the Qur'an's

egalitarian ethic and the lived realities of Pakistani women. This gap is not

simply a matter of implementation failure, though that is certainly part of the

problem. It is also a problem of interpretation. Conservative interpretations

have read patriarchal cultural norms into sacred texts, presenting as divine

command what is actually human construction. Liberal interpretations, while

often more aligned with the Qur'an's egalitarian spirit, have been unable to

overcome the perception that they are Western imports rather than authentic

Islamic positions. This study asks: What does a genuinely Islamic, contextually

sensitive, practically viable framework for women's development look like?

Research Objectives

This research has five objectives. First, to establish the conceptual and ethical

foundations of women's role in Islam—their status, rights, and

responsibilities—through fresh engagement with primary sources. Second, to

analyze the changing role of women in contemporary Pakistani society across

education, professional employment, family structures, public institutions, and

political leadership. Third, to identify persistent challenges facing Pakistani

women, including legal barriers, educational disparities, economic

discrimination, violence, and restrictive social norms. Fourth, to develop an

Islamic evaluation of contemporary changes that distinguishes between

authentic Islamic teachings and cultural patriarchy. Fifth, to propose a

balanced, practically viable model of women's development—family-centered

empowerment with ethical participation—along with concrete policy

recommendations.

Research Questions

129

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

This research addresses six core questions. First, what are the conceptual and

ethical foundations of women's status, rights, and responsibilities in the Qur'an

and Sunnah? Second, how have women's roles changed in contemporary

Pakistani society across education, employment, family, public life, and

politics? Third, what factors—legal, economic, social, cultural, and religious—

have facilitated or impeded these changes? Fourth, what persistent challenges

do Pakistani women face, and how do these manifest in empirical data? Fifth,

what does an Islamic evaluation of contemporary changes look like when

grounded in the Qur'an's egalitarian ethic rather than patriarchal

interpretations? Sixth, what would a balanced, practically viable model of

women's development look like for contemporary Pakistan?

Significance of the Study

This research makes several contributions. Theoretically, it moves beyond the

polarized discourse that pits "Islamic" against "modern" or "traditional"

against "feminist." It offers an internally grounded Islamic framework for

understanding and addressing women's issues that takes both sacred texts and

contemporary realities seriously. Methodologically, it integrates Islamic studies,

gender studies, and sociology, legal analysis, and policy evaluation— fields

rarely brought into productive dialogue. Practically, it offers concrete,

evidence-based guidance for policymakers, religious leaders, educators, civil

society organizations, and international development agencies working to

advance women's status in Pakistan.

Research Methodology

This research employs a qualitative, interdisciplinary methodology. The

inductive method gathers relevant Qur'anic verses, Hadith, classical legal texts,

contemporary Islamic scholarship, Pakistani legislation, development reports,

and peer-reviewed research. The analytical method examines these sources for

their conceptual significance, historical context, social implications, and policy

relevance. The comparative method places Islamic teachings alongside

empirical data from Pakistan and international frameworks like CEDAW and

SDGs. The case study method treats Pakistani society as a revealing case for

examining women's changing roles in Muslim-majority contexts. Primary

sources include the Qur'an, the six canonical Hadith collections, classical works

of tafsir and fiqh, and contemporary Islamic scholarship. Secondary sources

130

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

include Pakistan Demographic and Health Surveys, Pakistan Bureau of

Statistics data, UN Women Pakistan reports, UNICEF Pakistan reports,

UNESCO education data, World Bank Gender Data, and peer-reviewed

journal articles.

Section One: Conceptual and Ethical Foundations of Women's Role in Islam

This section establishes the conceptual and ethical foundations for

understanding women's role in Islam. Western scholarship has often

approached Islamic teachings on women through a framework of critique that

assumes Western modernity as the standard of measurement. Conservative

Muslim scholarship has often approached the same teachings through a

framework of preservation that resists any change as un-Islamic. Both

approaches fail to take seriously the internal logic of the Islamic tradition—its

sacred texts, its methods of interpretation, its ethical purposes, and its historical

development. The alternative adopted here is to begin with the Qur'an and

Sunnah themselves, reading them with attention to their historical context,

linguistic meaning, and ethical purposes, while also recognizing that the

classical jurists who developed Islamic law were brilliant scholars working

within their own historical contexts, not infallible interpreters whose

conclusions are binding for all time.

Two foundational points deserve emphasis from the outset. First, the Qur'an's

revelation in seventh-century Arabia occurred in a profoundly patriarchal

context where women were treated as property, denied inheritance, and

subjected to unlimited polygyny and unilateral divorce. Against this

background, the Qur'an's reforms—granting women inheritance rights,

restricting polygyny, regulating divorce, affirming women's spiritual equality—

were revolutionary. Second, the Prophet's teachings and practices established

concrete rights for women that exceeded anything in the surrounding culture,

while also embedding these rights within a framework of family cohesion,

mutual responsibility, and ethical conduct. The challenge for contemporary

Muslims is to distinguish between the eternal ethical principles of the tradition

and their historical embodiments, which were shaped by the cultural and

material conditions of their time.

1.1 The Concept of Womanhood in Islamic Thought

131

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

The Qur'an's foundational declaration regarding women's status appears in a

verse that affirms the spiritual equality of men and women. The revelation came

as a direct response to a woman who asked why the Qur'an addressed men only,

and the verse that followed included both male and female forms for every

virtue mentioned. This event itself demonstrates that the Qur'an was responsive

to women's concerns and that women were active participants in the religious

community, raising questions and seeking clarification.

A verse from Surah al-Hujurat establishes the basis for human dignity without

gender distinction:

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ً

ْ

َ

ُ

ن

إ

فوا

ا

لتع

ل

ئ

ا

قب

و

با

شعو

كم

نا

ل

جع

و

ثى

ن

أ

ر

ذك

ن

م

كم

قنا

ل

خ

ا

ن

إ

س

نا

ال

ا

أيه

ا

ي

﴿

ر

و

ِ

ٍ

َ

ُ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

¹﴾

كم

تقا

أ

ꢁ

د

ن

ع

م

ك

م

ر

أك

ِ

Translation: "O humanity, indeed We have created you from a

male and a female, and made you peoples and tribes that you

may know one another. Indeed, the most noble of you in the

sight of God is the most righteous of you."

This verse directly challenges any hierarchy based on gender. The creation

narrative—male and female from a single source—establishes fundamental

equality. The diversity of peoples and tribes is for recognition, not competition

or domination. The sole criterion of nobility before God is righteousness, a

quality accessible to both men and women equally. Pakistani feminist activists

have invoked this verse to challenge discriminatory laws and practices, arguing

that any policy or custom that treats women as inherently inferior contradicts

this clear Qur'anic teaching.

The mutual relationship between spouses is described in another foundational

verse:

َ

ُ

ْ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ٌ

²﴾

ن

له

س

ا

لب

تم

ن

أ

م

ك

ل

س

ا

لب

ن

ه

﴿

و

ِ

Translation: "They are clothing for you and you are clothing for

them."

The clothing metaphor is rich with meaning. Clothing provides protection,

warmth, and covering. It is close to the body and essential for well-being.

Neither spouse is described as the clothing of the other in a one-directional

way; the relationship is mutual and reciprocal. This verse establishes the marital

relationship as one of mutual protection, support, and intimacy—not

hierarchy, domination, or submission. Pakistani family law, which often treats

132

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

wives as subordinate to husbands, stands in tension with this Qur'anic vision

of mutuality.

The Qur'an also commands kind treatment of women, recognizing their rights

and dignity:

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

و

³﴾

ف

ر

لع

ا

ْ

ب

ن

ه

ر

ش

وعا

﴿

ِ

Translation: "And live with them in kindness."

The term "maʿrūf" (kindness, good custom, what is recognized as good) is a

key Qur'anic concept. It refers to practices that are ethically good, socially

recognized as proper, and consonant with human dignity. The command to

live with women in kindness is not optional but obligatory. Any treatment of

women that violates this standard—whether physical abuse, psychological

cruelty, economic deprivation, or social restriction—contravenes this Qur'anic

command.

Classical exegete Abū Bakr al-Jaṣṣāṣ, in his commentary on this verse, writes:

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

ُ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

و

ل

م

ح

وت

،

م

ل

َ

ك

ال

ب

ي

ط

و

،

لق

خ

ل

ا

ن

حس

ل

م

ش

ي

ك

ذل

و

،

ف

ر

لع

ا

ْ

ب

ن

ه

ت

ر

ش

ا

ع

بم

ꢁ

مر

أ

«

ِ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

ُ

و

⁴»

ف

ر

لع

ا

ْ

ب

ن

ه

ي

ل

ع

ق

ا

نف

ل

ْ

ا

و

،

ى

لذ

ا

ْ

Translation: "God commanded living with them in kindness,

and this includes good character, pleasant speech, bearing

hardship, and spending upon them in a proper manner."

ِ

Al-Jaṣṣāṣ enumerates specific obligations: good character (not harshness or

cruelty), pleasant speech (not verbal abuse), bearing hardship (patience with

differences), and proper financial support. This comprehensive understanding

of kindness provides a framework for evaluating marital practices in

contemporary Pakistan. Arranged marriages, while not prohibited, must respect

the woman's consent. Domestic violence, verbal abuse, and economic

deprivation are explicitly condemned by this Qur'anic command.

The Prophet's own practice exemplified this command. His treatment of his

wives was marked by gentleness, consultation, and affection. He helped with

household chores, joked with his wives, and consulted them on important

matters. When one of his wives expressed dissatisfaction, he listened and

responded kindly. This example is directly relevant to contemporary debates

about marital roles and relationships.

133

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

Contemporary Islamic scholar Abdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im argues: "The

historical experience of Muslim societies demonstrates that Sharia has been

interpreted and applied in diverse ways across time and place. Muslims today

have both the right and the responsibility to reinterpret Sharia principles in

light of contemporary conditions, provided they remain faithful to the

fundamental purposes of Islamic law: justice, human dignity, and the common

good."⁵ An-Na'im's approach, known as the "constitutional mediation" of

Sharia, opens space for reform without abandoning the authority of the

tradition. Pakistani legal reform efforts, he suggests, should be grounded in

Islamic principles rather than presented as Western impositions.

Pakistani Supreme Court Justice (Retired) Nasira Iqbal writes: "The Pakistani

Constitution guarantees fundamental rights without discrimination on grounds

of sex. But constitutional guarantees are not self-executing. They require

enabling legislation, judicial enforcement, and social change. The gap between

constitutional promise and lived reality is where most Pakistani women struggle

daily. Bridging this gap requires not only legal reform but also religious

education that presents Islam's egalitarian message accurately, not filtered

through patriarchal cultural lenses."⁶ Her observation highlights the

importance of both legal and cultural change, and the role of religious

education in challenging patriarchal interpretations.

1.2 Rights and Responsibilities Under Islamic Law

Islamic law grants women rights that were unprecedented in seventh-century

Arabia and remain contested in contemporary Pakistan. The right to own and

manage property independently is established in the Qur'an's recognition of

women's financial agency. A woman's property before marriage remains her

own after marriage; her husband has no right to it without her consent. This

economic independence is a foundation for other rights.

A verse from Surah al-Nisa addresses women's property rights directly:

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ٌ

َ

ٌ

⁷﴾

ن

ب

س

ت

اك

ا

م

يب

ص

ن

ء

سا

ن

ل

و

بوا

س

ت

اك

ا

م

يب

ص

ن

ل

ا

ج

ر

ل

﴿

ِ

Translation: "For men is a share of what they have earned, and

for women is a share of what they have earned."

This verse establishes the principle that both men and women have

independent claims to their earnings. A woman's earnings are her own property;

she is not required to contribute to household expenses, though she may choose

134

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

to do so. This economic independence protects women from financial coercion

and enables them to leave abusive or unsatisfactory marriages. In contemporary

Pakistan, however, many women are unaware of this right, and social norms

pressure them to transfer control of their earnings to male family members.

Legal literacy programs that educate women about their Islamic financial rights

are essential.

The right to consent to marriage is established in the Prophet's explicit

teaching:

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

ُ

َ

ُ

⁸»

أمر

ت

س

ت

ى

ت

ح

يب

ث

ال

ح

نك

ت

ل

و

َ

،

ذن

أ

ت

س

ت

ى

ت

كرح

الب

ح

نك

ت

ل

َ

«

ِ

Translation: "A virgin should not be married until her

permission is sought, and a previously married woman should

not be married until her consent is obtained."

The Prophet distinguishes between the virgin (bikr), who may be shy and

whose silence is considered consent, and the previously married woman

(thayyib), whose explicit consent is required. The principle is clear: marriage

requires the woman's free consent. Forced marriage—marriage without

consent—is invalid under Islamic law. Pakistani law criminalizes forced

marriage, but enforcement is weak, and social norms often pressure women to

comply with family decisions. Religious education emphasizing the woman's

right to consent is essential for changing these practices.

The right to divorce is recognized in Islamic law, though the procedures differ

between men and women. Men have the unilateral right of ṭalāq (repudiation).

Women have the right to seek divorce through khulʿ (divestiture) or judicial

dissolution. A verse in Surah al-Baqarah establishes khulʿ:

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

⁹﴾

به

ت

افتد

ا

م

ي

ف

ا

م

ه

ي

ل

ع

ح

نا

ج

ل

َ

ف

﴿

ِ

Translation: "There is no blame upon them for what she gives

up to obtain her freedom."

This verse permits a woman to initiate divorce by returning her dowry or

forgoing her financial rights. The Prophet approved khulʿ in cases where a

woman found her husband repulsive and feared she could not uphold her

marital duties. This establishes that marriage is not an indissoluble bond;

women who are trapped in unhappy or abusive marriages have a legitimate

Islamic mechanism for exiting. Pakistani family courts grant khulʿ, but the

135

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

process can be lengthy, costly, and socially stigmatizing. Reforms that make

khulʿ more accessible and less stigmatized would align with Islamic principles.

The responsibility to provide for the family rests primarily on men in classical

Islamic law. A verse in Surah al-Nisa establishes this allocation:

َ

ْ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

ن

م

وا

ق

نف

أ

ا

م

وب

عض

ب

ى

ل

ع

هم

ض

ع

ب

ꢁ

ضل

ف

ا

بم

ء

سا

ن

ال

ى

ل

ع

و

م

قوا

ل

ا

ج

ر

ال

﴿

ِ

ٍ

ِ

َ

ْ

¹⁰﴾

والهم

م

أ

ِ

Translation: "Men are maintainers and protectors of women

because God has given some of them advantage over others and

because they spend of their wealth."

The term "qawwāmūn" has been subject to extensive debate. Classical

interpretations read it as "in authority over," implying male leadership and

female obedience. Contemporary interpreters, reading the verse in light of its

context and the Qur'an's overall egalitarian ethic, argue that "qawwāmūn"

means "responsible for" or "providers for." The justification given is twofold:

natural differences (which may be biological, social, or both) and financial

responsibility. If a woman is financially independent, the rationale for male

authority diminishes. This interpretation opens space for alternative family

arrangements where both spouses contribute financially and share decision-

making authority.

Classical exegete Muḥammad al-Ṭabarī, in his comprehensive commentary,

notes multiple interpretations of this verse:

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

ل

ا

ق

و

،

ي

ه

ن

ال

مرو

ل

ا

ْ

و

ية

ل

و

َ

ل

ا

ي

ه

:

هم

ض

ع

ب

ل

قا

ف

،

ة

م

وا

ق

ال

ى

ن

ع

م

ي

ف

ل

ي

أو

الت

هل

أ

ف

ل

اخت

«

ِ

ُ

ْ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

ُ

ْ

َ

ر

¹¹»

و

م

ل

ا

ْ

ب

م

قيا

ال

و

ة

و

كس

ال

و

ة

ق

ف

ن

ال

ي

ه

:

هم

ض

ع

ب

ِ

Translation: "Interpreters differ regarding the meaning of

qiwāmah. Some say it means authority and commanding and

forbidding. Others say it means spending, clothing, and

attending to affairs."

Al-Ṭabarī's honest reporting of interpretive disagreement is significant. The

classical tradition did not have a single, fixed interpretation of this verse. The

existence of multiple interpretations, including one that emphasizes financial

provision rather than authority, provides contemporary Muslims with

resources for developing interpretations more aligned with egalitarian ethics.

136

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

Contemporary Pakistani scholar Javed Ahmad Ghamidi reads this verse

functionally: "The responsibility for family maintenance is assigned to men

because of their traditional role as earners. If women become earners and

contribute equally, the rationale for male authority diminishes. What matters

is the function—ensuring the family's needs are met—not the gender of the

person performing it."¹² Ghamidi's functional reading is controversial but

grounded in classical interpretive methods. It suggests that as Pakistani women

increasingly contribute to family income, family authority structures can and

should adjust accordingly.

1.3 The Purposes of Islamic Law and Women's Development

Islamic law's higher purposes (maqāṣid al-sharīʿah) provide a framework for

evaluating women's development. The classical formulation by Abū Ḥāmid al-

Ghazālī and al-Shāṭibī identifies five essential purposes: protection of life,

religion, intellect, lineage, and property. Women's development serves each of

these purposes. Education protects intellect. Economic participation protects

property. Health care protects life. Family stability protects lineage. Religious

knowledge protects faith.

A verse from Surah al-Raʿd expresses the principle of collective responsibility:

َ

ُ

ْ

َ

َ َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

ُ

¹³﴾

هم

س

نف

أ

ب

ا

م

ا

و

ر

ي

غ

ي

ى

ت

ح

م

و

ق

ب

ما

ر

ي

غ

ي

ل

َ

ꢁ

إن

﴿

ِ

ٍ

ِ

Translation: "Indeed, God does not change the condition of a

people until they change what is in themselves."

This verse is often invoked to emphasize personal responsibility for change. It

applies equally to societies: change in women's condition requires not only legal

reform but also changes in social attitudes, cultural norms, and individual

behavior. Pakistani women cannot wait passively for change to come from

above; they must be active agents of their own development. At the same time,

structural barriers must be removed. The verse implies a dialectic between

individual agency and social structure—both matter, and both must change.

The principle of justice (ʿadl) runs throughout the Qur'an. A verse in Surah al-

Nisā' commands:

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

ْ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ن

الوالدي

و

أ

م

سك

نف

أ

ى

ل

ع

لو

و

ꢂ

شهداء

قسط

ل

ا

ب

ن

ي

م

قوا

وا

ن

كو

وا

من

آ

ن

ي

ذ

ال

ا

أيه

ا

ي

﴿

ِ

َ

ْ

َ

¹⁴﴾

ن

ي

ب

ر

ق

ل

ا

ْ

و

ِ

137

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

Translation: "O you who believe, be persistently standing firm

in justice, witnesses for God, even if against yourselves or your

parents or close relatives."

Justice is not selective; it applies to all, including when it is inconvenient or

when it goes against one's own interests or family ties. Discriminatory practices

against women—denying education, employment, inheritance, or legal

protection—violate this command. Those who defend such practices as Islamic

are, from this perspective, violating Islam's core commitment to justice.

Classical jurist al-Shāṭibī, in his foundational work on maqāṣid, writes:

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

ٌ

َ

ُ

ٌ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

،

ا

ه

ل

ك

ة

م

ح

،

ا

ه

ل

ك

لة

عاد

ي

ه

و

،

ة

ر

خ

ل

ا

ْ

و

يا

ن

الد

ي

ف

اد

العب

ح

ل

ا

ص

م

ى

ل

ع

ة

ي

ن

ب

م

عة

ي

شر

ال

«

ر

ِ

َ

ُ

ٌ

َ

ْ

َ

¹⁵»

ا

ه

ل

ك

ة

ح

ل

ص

م

Translation: "Islamic law is built upon the welfare of people in

this life and the next. It is entirely justice, entirely mercy, entirely

welfare."

Any interpretation of Islamic law that produces injustice, cruelty, or harm to

women cannot be correct, because the law's essential character is just and

merciful. This principle provides a powerful tool for critiquing patriarchal

interpretations that cause harm to women. If a practice—such as denying girls

education—produces injustice, it cannot be authentically Islamic, regardless of

how it is justified.

Contemporary maqāṣid scholar Jasser Auda applies this framework to

women's issues: "The purposes of Islamic law include justice, equality, and

human dignity. Any interpretation that violates these purposes, even if based

on literal readings of texts, must be reconsidered because it contradicts the law's

essential nature. The maqāṣid approach provides a methodology for reforming

traditional interpretations that have become unjust or harmful in changed

circumstances."¹⁶ This approach is particularly relevant for Pakistani legal

reform, where conservative interpretations often block progress on women's

rights.

Section Two: Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Pakistani Society

This section examines the changing role of women in contemporary Pakistani

society across five domains: education, professional employment, family

structures, public institutions, and political leadership. The story is complex,

marked by genuine progress alongside persistent challenges. More women are

138

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

educated than ever before, yet most remain outside the formal workforce. More

women participate in politics, yet substantive influence remains limited. Family

structures are changing, yet patriarchal authority remains resilient. Women are

increasingly visible in public life, yet face discrimination, harassment, and

violence. Understanding this complexity is essential for developing effective

strategies for women's advancement.

Several factors have driven change. Economic development has created new

employment opportunities for educated women. Urbanization has weakened

extended family control over women's mobility. Education has expanded

women's aspirations and capabilities. Media exposure has introduced new

images of womanhood and catalyzed feminist activism. Legal reforms, though

inconsistently enforced, have established new rights and protections. At the

same time, persistent barriers include patriarchal social norms, weak

implementation of protective laws, inadequate support services for working

women, and conservative religious interpretations that restrict women's roles.

2.1 Women's Education and Professional Advancement

Pakistan has made significant progress in girls' education over the past three

decades, yet substantial gaps remain. The constitution guarantees free and

compulsory education for all children aged 5-16, but implementation has been

uneven. Primary enrollment for girls has increased from 52% in 2000 to 78%

in 2022, but 22% of primary-aged girls remain out of school. The gender gap

widens at secondary and tertiary levels, with girls' enrollment dropping

significantly after primary school due to early marriage, household

responsibilities, lack of female teachers, inadequate facilities, and cultural

norms restricting girls' mobility.

A Hadith recorded by Ibn Mājah emphasizes the importance of seeking

knowledge for every Muslim:

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

ٌ

َ

ْ

ُ

¹⁷»

م

ل

س

م

ل

ك

ى

ل

ع

ة

ض

ي

ر

ف

م

ل

الع

ب

ل

ط

«

ِ

ٍ

ِ

Translation: "Seeking knowledge is an obligation upon every

Muslim."

This Hadith does not distinguish between male and female Muslims. The

obligation applies equally to both. Those who prevent girls from seeking

education are, from this perspective, violating a clear Prophetic command.

Pakistani activists have invoked this Hadith to advocate for girls' education,

139

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

arguing that cultural practices restricting girls' schooling are un-Islamic. The

Hadith has been cited in court cases challenging school closures and in

advocacy campaigns promoting girls' enrollment.

The Qur'an also emphasizes the value of knowledge and the equality of those

who possess it:

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

ُ

ْ

ن

ي

¹⁸﴾

و

لم

ع

ي

ل

َ

ن

ي

ذ

ال

و

لم

ع

ي

ن

ي

ذ

ال

تو

س

ي

ل

ه

ل

ق

﴿

ِ

Translation: "Say: Are those who know equal to those who do

not know?"

This verse establishes a hierarchy based on knowledge, not gender. Those who

know—whether male or female—are superior to those who do not know.

Societies that deprive women of education are thus perpetuating ignorance

among half their population, which the Qur'an does not value. The verse has

been used by Pakistani educational reformers to argue for equal investment in

girls' and boys' education.

In higher education, women's enrollment has surpassed men's in some

universities, particularly in urban areas and in fields like medicine, education,

and the humanities. However, this increase reflects limited employment options

for educated women as much as genuine educational advancement. Many

educated young women remain unemployed or underemployed, their skills and

aspirations unmet. The transition from education to employment remains

difficult due to gender discrimination in hiring, lack of safe transportation,

workplace harassment, and family opposition to women working outside the

home.

The Pakistan Demographic and Health Survey 2022-23 reports that female

literacy among young women (aged 15-24) has reached 70%, up from 55% in

2010. However, regional disparities are stark: in urban Sindh, female literacy

exceeds 85%; in rural Balochistan, it remains below 35%. These disparities

reflect uneven economic development, differential investment in education

infrastructure, and regional variation in cultural norms. Targeted

interventions—stipends for girls' education, community schools, mobile girls'

education programs—have shown positive results in high-disparity districts,

suggesting that progress is possible with sustained political will.

Women's labor force participation in Pakistan remains among the lowest in

the world at approximately 22%, compared to 82% for men. The World Bank

140

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

Gender Data Portal reports that this aggregate figure masks significant

variation: educated urban women have participation rates approaching 40%,

while rural uneducated women have rates below 10%. The correlation between

education and labor force participation underscores the importance of girls'

education for women's economic empowerment. However, education alone is

insufficient; women face discrimination in hiring, occupational segregation,

wage gaps, and lack of childcare facilities.

The Prophet's encouragement of seeking beneficial knowledge, regardless of

gender, is recorded in multiple traditions:

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ً

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ً

َ

ُ

¹⁹»

ة

جن

ل

ا

ى

ل

إ

قا

ي

ر

ط

به

ه

ل

ꢁ

ل

ه

س

،

ا

لم

ع

ه

ي

ف

س

م

ت

ل

ي

قا

ي

ر

ط

لك

س

ن

م

«

ِ

Translation: "Whoever travels a path seeking knowledge, God

makes easy for him a path to paradise."

The promise of paradise for knowledge seekers applies equally to women.

Pakistani women scholars, scientists, doctors, and engineers who have excelled

in their fields often invoke this Hadith to ground their professional pursuits in

religious motivation. The Hadith reframes education and professional

achievement as spiritual endeavors, not merely worldly pursuits. This reframing

is important in a society where religious conservatives sometimes characterize

women's education and employment as Western or un-Islamic.

2.2 Women in Family, Society and Public Life

The family remains the primary site of gender role construction and

reproduction in Pakistani society. Patriarchal structures persist, but they are

not static. Economic pressures, urbanization, education, and media exposure

have all contributed to changes in family structures and expectations. The joint

family system is under strain as nuclear families become more common,

particularly in urban areas. Women's roles as wives, mothers, daughters-in-law,

and household managers are being negotiated and contested.

A verse from Surah al-Rūm describes the marital relationship as a sign of God's

power and mercy:

َ

ُ

ً

َ

ُ

ْ

ُ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ً

َ

ْ

َ

و

ة

د

و

م

نك

ي

ب

ل

جع

و

ا

ه

ي

إل

وا

سكن

ت

ل

ا

اج

أز

م

سك

نف

أ

ن

م

ك

ل

لق

خ

أن

ه

ات

آي

ن

وم

﴿

ِ

ً

ْ

َ

ر

²⁰﴾

ة

م

ح

و

141

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

Translation: "And of His signs is that He created for you from

yourselves spouses that you may find tranquility in them, and He

placed between you affection and mercy."

The marital ideal is tranquility, affection, and mercy—not hierarchy, control,

or violence. Pakistani family law and social practice often fall short of this ideal.

Domestic violence remains widespread: the Pakistan Demographic and Health

Survey reports that 34% of ever-married women have experienced physical,

sexual, or emotional violence from their husbands. This reality contradicts the

Qur'anic vision of marriage as a source of tranquility. Feminist activists have

invoked this verse to challenge domestic violence, arguing that violent marriages

violate the fundamental purpose of marriage in Islamic law.

The Prophet explicitly prohibited violence against women and commanded

kindness:

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ً

²¹»

دكم

عن

وان

ع

ء

سا

ن

ال

ن

إ

ف

،

ا

ر

ي

خ

ء

سا

ن

ل

ا

ب

وا

ص

تو

س

ا

«

ِ

ٍ

ِ

Translation: "Treat women kindly. They are like captives in

your hands."

The phrase "like captives in your hands" reflects the historical reality of

women's vulnerability, not an endorsement of treating women as captives. The

Prophet used this realistic description to emphasize the responsibility of men

to treat women with kindness, given their vulnerability. This Hadith is often

cited in Pakistani domestic violence awareness campaigns to emphasize that

kind treatment is not optional but a religious duty.

Social expectations regarding gender roles are changing, but slowly. A 2022

survey by the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics found that 65%

of urban Pakistanis support women working outside the home, compared to

40% in rural areas. However, even among supporters, most believe that

women's work should not interfere with their domestic responsibilities. This

double burden—paid work plus unpaid domestic labor—remains a major

challenge for employed women. Pakistani working women spend an average of

4-5 hours per day on domestic work in addition to their paid employment,

compared to 1-2 hours for working men. Lack of childcare facilities, household

help, and supportive workplace policies exacerbates this burden.

Women's participation in public institutions has increased but remains limited.

Women hold reserved seats in Parliament (60 seats reserved for women in the

142

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

National Assembly) and in provincial assemblies, but their substantive

influence is often constrained by patriarchal party structures and male-

dominated decision-making processes. The 18th Amendment (2010) devolved

significant authority to provinces, including responsibility for social welfare

programs benefiting women, but implementation has been uneven. Women

judges serve in higher courts but remain a small minority. Women police

officers face discrimination, harassment, and assignment to less prestigious

roles.

The Qur'an establishes the principle of mutual consultation within families and

communities:

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

ُ

َ

ْ

ُ

ر

²²﴾

هم

ن

ي

ب

ى

شو

م

ه

ر

م

أ

و

﴿

Translation: "And their affairs are conducted by mutual

consultation."

This verse, describing the believers, establishes consultation as a norm. While

often applied to political governance, the principle extends to family decision-

making. Pakistani women who are excluded from family financial decisions,

marriage decisions for their children, and other important matters are denied

the consultation that the Qur'an establishes as a norm for believers. Education

and empowerment enable women to participate meaningfully in family

consultation.

2.3 Media, Globalization and the Transformation of Women's Identity

Globalization and media expansion have transformed women's aspirations,

self-perceptions, and social possibilities. Satellite television, social media, and

internet access expose Pakistani women to diverse images of womanhood—

from Western feminist icons to Turkish drama heroines to Indian Bollywood

stars. These images create new desires and possibilities but also new tensions

and contradictions.

A verse from Surah al-Ḥujurāt provides guidance for engaging with cultural

diversity:

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ً

ْ

َ

ُ

²³﴾

فوا

ا

لتع

ل

ئ

ا

قب

و

ا

ب

شعو

كم

نا

ل

جع

و

ثى

ن

أ

ر

ذك

ن

م

كم

قنا

ل

خ

ا

ن

إ

س

نا

ال

ا

أيه

ا

ي

﴿

ر

و

ِ

ٍ

Translation: "O humanity, indeed We have created you from a

male and a female, and made you peoples and tribes that you

may know one another."

143

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

Diversity is divinely willed. The purpose is mutual recognition, not warfare or

domination. Globalization, properly understood, enables the mutual

recognition that the Qur'an values. However, cultural exchange should be

selective and critical, not passive adoption. Pakistani women navigating

globalization must distinguish between practices consistent with Islamic values

and those that are not. The Prophet's practice of selectively retaining pre-

Islamic customs consistent with justice while reforming or abolishing

oppressive ones provides a model for this critical engagement.

The impact of social media on women's identity formation is particularly

significant. Platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok allow women to

present curated versions of themselves, connect with like-minded others, and

access information and networks previously unavailable. Women's rights

activists use social media to mobilize support, document abuses, and challenge

patriarchal norms. The #MeToo movement in Pakistan, though smaller than

in Western countries, has enabled women to share experiences of harassment

and demand accountability. However, social media also enables harassment,

surveillance, and cyber-violence against women. The Pakistan government has

passed the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (2016), which criminalizes

cyber-harassment, but enforcement remains weak, and many women hesitate to

report due to fear of social stigma or inadequate police response.

Pakistani media studies scholar Fariha Zafar notes: "Digital spaces create new

possibilities for women's empowerment. Young women who are restricted

from physical mobility find virtual mobility through smartphones. They access

information, education, and social networks that were previously unavailable.

However, this virtual mobility also creates new risks: online harassment,

surveillance by family members, and the pressure to conform to curated images

of perfect womanhood on social media."²⁴ This dual nature of digital space—

opportunity and risk—requires nuanced policy responses that protect women's

digital rights while enabling their digital participation.

The challenge of identity formation is particularly acute for young, educated,

urban Pakistani women. They navigate multiple, sometimes conflicting,

identities: modern and traditional, professional and domestic, individualistic

and family-oriented, global and local. Many report feeling torn between the

aspirations enabled by their education and the expectations embedded in their

144

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

families and communities. This internal conflict is a significant source of

psychological distress. Studies of Pakistani professional women report high

rates of stress, anxiety, and depression, often related to role conflict and the

pressure to excel in multiple domains without adequate support.

Section Three: Islamic Evaluation of Contemporary Changes and Future

Directions

This section evaluates contemporary changes in women's roles from an Islamic

perspective and proposes a balanced model for women's development. The

evaluation distinguishes between changes consistent with Islamic ethical

principles and those that may conflict with them. The proposed model—

family-centered empowerment with ethical participation—rejects both

Western individualistic feminism and conservative patriarchal restriction,

offering instead a distinctly Islamic vision.

3.1 Contemporary Challenges Facing Women in Pakistan

Pakistani women face multiple, intersecting challenges. Work-life balance is a

persistent struggle for employed women, who bear disproportionate

responsibility for childcare, elder care, and household management. The Qur'an

recognizes the importance of balance and prohibits overburdening:

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

ُ

َ

ْ

ُ

ً

²⁵﴾

ا

عه

س

و

ل

َ

إ

سا

نف

ꢁ

ف

ل

ك

ي

ل

َ

﴿

ِ

Translation: "God does not burden a soul beyond its capacity."

This verse establishes a principle against excessive burden. Yet many Pakistani

working women experience excessive burden due to the combination of paid

work and unpaid domestic responsibilities. Addressing this requires structural

changes: paid parental leave, workplace childcare facilities, flexible work

arrangements, and social norms that encourage men's participation in domestic

work.

Gender-based discrimination in employment persists. The Constitution

prohibits discrimination on grounds of sex, but enforcement is weak. A verse

from Surah al-Nisā' commands fair treatment:

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

²⁶﴾

قسط

ل

ا

ب

ن

ي

م

قوا

وا

ن

كو

وا

من

آ

ن

ي

ذ

ال

ا

أيه

ا

ي

﴿

ِ

Translation: "O you who believe, be persistently standing firm

in justice."

Justice in employment means equal pay for equal work, fair hiring and

promotion practices, and protection from harassment and discrimination.

145

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

Pakistani labor law includes these provisions, but implementation is weak, and

many women are unaware of their rights. Women's wages in Pakistan are

approximately 60% of men's wages for comparable work, with the gap wider

in the private sector than in the public sector.

Violence against women remains widespread. The Qur'an explicitly prohibits

violence and aggression:

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

َ َ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

²⁷﴾

ن

عتدي

ل

ا

ْ

ب

يح

ل

َ

ꢁ

إن

ا

و

عتد

ت

ل

و

َ

﴿

ِ

Translation: "And do not commit aggression. Indeed, God does

not love the aggressors."

Domestic violence, honor killings, and other forms of violence against women

are aggression, prohibited by this verse. Pakistani law criminalizes domestic

violence and honor killings, but implementation is weak, and many cases go

unreported due to social stigma, fear of reprisal, and lack of confidence in the

justice system. The Protection of Women Against Violence Act (2016) has

been passed in several provinces, but its implementation varies, and conservative

opposition has delayed enforcement in some areas.

Legal challenges include gaps between constitutional guarantees, statutory law,

and personal status laws. The Constitution prohibits discrimination, but

personal status laws (applicable to Muslims) treat women and men differently

in matters of marriage, divorce, inheritance, and child custody. For example, a

man's right to unilateral divorce (ṭalāq) is recognized, while a woman must go

through the more cumbersome judicial khulʿ process. A man's right to marry

up to four wives is recognized, while a woman's right to polyandry is not. These

differential treatments are based on classical Islamic jurisprudence, but they are

increasingly contested. Reformist scholars argue that the conditions attached

to polygyny in the Qur'an (justice, equality among wives) are impossible to

meet, making polygyny effectively prohibited. Similar arguments are made

about the need to reform ṭalāq procedures to prevent arbitrary, unilateral

divorce.

3.2 Islamic Responses to Contemporary Women's Issues

Islamic responses to contemporary women's issues must be grounded in the

Qur'an's egalitarian ethic, the Prophet's practice, and the higher purposes of

Islamic law. The Qur'an establishes the principle of consultation:

146

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

ّ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ُ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ف

اع

ف

ك

ول

ح

ن

م

وا

ض

نف

ل

َ

ب

ل

ق

ال

ظ

ي

ل

غ

ا

ظ

ف

ت

ن

وك

ل

و

لهم

ت

ن

ل

ꢁ

ن

م

ة

م

ح

ا

م

فب

﴿

ر

ٍ

ِ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

ُ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

ر

²⁸﴾

مر

ل

ا

ْ

ي

ف

م

ه

او

ش

و

لهم

ر

ف

تغ

س

ا

و

هم

عن

ِ

Translation: "So by mercy from God, you were lenient with

them. And if you had been rude and harsh-hearted, they would

have disbanded from around you. So pardon them and ask

forgiveness for them and consult them in the matter."

The Prophet was commanded to consult his Companions, both male and

female. The Qur'an does not specify that consultation is limited to men.

Women's participation in consultation—in families, communities, and

governance—is consistent with this prophetic model. Pakistani institutions

that exclude women from decision-making violate this Qur'anic command.

Family-centered empowerment, as an alternative to both Western

individualism and patriarchal restriction, recognizes the family as the primary

unit of social organization and seeks to empower women within families, not

in opposition to them. A verse from Surah al-Nisā' describes family

relationships:

َ

ْ

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

ن

²⁹﴾

م

حا

ل

ا

ْ

و

به

ءلو

سا

ت

ي

ذ

ال

ꢁ

وا

ش

اخ

و

﴿

ر

ِ

Translation: "And fear God through whom you ask one another,

and fear the breaking of kinship ties."

Family ties are sacred. Empowerment that severs family ties or sets women

against their families is not consistent with Islamic values. Empowerment that

strengthens families, improves family well-being, and enhances women's roles

within families is consistent. This framework supports policies that enable

women to balance work and family, such as parental leave, flexible work

arrangements, and childcare support.

Ethical participation in public life is possible within Islamic parameters. The

Qur'an commands believers to enjoin good and forbid evil:

ْ

ُ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ْ

ُ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

َ

ْ

ُ

ْ

َ

ُ

َ

ن

و

³⁰﴾

نكر

ل

ا

ْ

ن

ع

هو

وتن

ف

ر

ع

ل

ا

ْ

ب

ن

تأمر

س

نا

ل

ت

ج

ر

أخ

ة

م

أ

ر

ي

خ

تم

ن

ك

﴿

ٍ

ِ

Translation: "You are the best nation produced for humanity,

enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong."

This duty applies to both men and women. Women's participation in public

life—as educators, healthcare providers, social workers, lawyers, judges,

legislators, and activists—is one way of fulfilling this duty. The conditions for

such participation include maintaining modesty (ḥijāb), avoiding gender

147

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

mixing where it leads to impropriety, and prioritizing family responsibilities

when they conflict. These conditions are not absolute barriers but guidelines

that can be met with appropriate accommodations.

3.3 Towards a Balanced Model of Women's Development in Pakistan

The proposed model—family-centered empowerment with ethical

participation—harmonizes Islamic values with contemporary realities. It rejects

both the Western individualistic model that prioritizes individual autonomy

over family cohesion and the traditional patriarchal model that subordinates

women's interests to male authority. The Qur'an provides guidance for balance:

ُ

ْ

ً

َ

ً

ُ

َ

ْ

َ

³¹﴾

ا

سط

و

ة

م

أ

كم

نا

ل

جع

ك

ل

ذ

ك

و

﴿

ِ

Translation: "And thus We have made you a middle nation."

The concept of wasaṭ (middle, balanced) applies to all aspects of Islamic life,

including women's roles. Extremes are to be avoided. The balanced path is

neither Westernization nor seclusion. This balance is what the proposed model

seeks to achieve.

Policy recommendations emerging from this model include several priorities.

First, legal reforms should harmonize personal status laws with constitutional

guarantees of equality, while maintaining fidelity to Islamic principles. This

includes reforming ṭalāq procedures, requiring court registration of divorce,

establishing clear criteria for polygyny (including judicial permission), and

equalizing inheritance for daughters and sons where family needs permit.

Second, education policies should prioritize girls' education through targeted

stipends, female teacher recruitment, safe transport, and community awareness

programs countering opposition to girls' schooling. Third, economic policies

should enable women's employment through workplace childcare facilities,

paid parental leave, flexible work arrangements, anti-harassment enforcement,

and skills training programs. Fourth, political participation should go beyond

reserved seats to include party reforms that enable women to contest general

seats and substantive influence. Fifth, social protection programs should

support working mothers, single mothers, widows, and other vulnerable women

through cash transfers, healthcare, and legal aid.

The way forward requires partnership among multiple actors. Government

must enact and enforce protective laws and allocate resources for women's

148

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

development. Religious scholars must articulate and disseminate

interpretations supporting women's rights and participation. Civil society must

advocate, monitor, and provide services. International organizations must

support and coordinate efforts. And women themselves must be active agents

of their own development, claiming their rights and fulfilling their

responsibilities.

Summary of Discussion

This research has examined the changing role of women in contemporary

Pakistani society from an interdisciplinary Islamic perspective. The study

found that the Qur'an and Sunnah provide a strong foundation for women's

rights and development, including the right to education, economic

participation, consent to marriage, divorce, and public engagement. The

classical juristic tradition, while developing in patriarchal contexts, contains

resources for reform, including interpretive flexibility, recognition of changing

customs, and commitment to justice.

Pakistani women have made significant progress over recent decades in

education, professional employment, and public participation. However,

substantial gaps remain between formal rights and lived realities. Persistent

challenges include educational disparities, occupational segregation, the double

burden of paid work and domestic labor, violence against women, legal gaps

between constitutional guarantees and personal status laws, and restrictive

social norms resistant to change.

The study proposed a balanced model of women's development—family-

centered empowerment with ethical participation—that harmonizes Islamic

values with contemporary realities. This model rejects both Western

individualistic feminism and conservative patriarchal restriction, offering

instead a distinctly Islamic vision grounded in the Qur'an's egalitarian ethic,

the Prophet's practice, and the higher purposes of Islamic law. Policy

recommendations include legal reforms, educational investments, economic

enablement, political participation, and social protection.

The study's limitations include its reliance on secondary data for some

empirical claims and its focus on Pakistan rather than comparative analysis

across Muslim-majority contexts. Future research should include primary data

collection on women's experiences, comparative analysis with other countries,

149

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

and evaluation of specific policy interventions. The changing role of women in

Pakistan will continue to evolve, shaped by economic development,

globalization, social movements, and ongoing contestation over Islamic

interpretation. This study offers a framework for understanding and guiding

that evolution in a direction faithful to Islamic principles and responsive to

contemporary realities.

Recommendations

For Government: Enact and enforce laws protecting women from violence,

discrimination, and harassment. Harmonize personal status laws with

constitutional equality guarantees. Allocate resources for girls' education,

women's health, and women's economic empowerment. Implement workplace

policies supporting working mothers: parental leave, childcare facilities, and

flexible arrangements. Strengthen enforcement of anti-harassment laws.

Support women's political participation beyond reserved seats.

For Religious Scholars and Institutions: Develop and disseminate

interpretations of Islamic sources that support women's rights and

participation in education, employment, and public life. Counter patriarchal

interpretations that restrict women's opportunities. Provide religious education

for girls and women. Issue fatwas clarifying women's rights under Islamic law.

Support legal reforms that align with Islamic principles and serve women's

welfare.

For Civil Society Organizations: Advocate for legal reform and

implementation. Provide legal aid, counseling, and shelter for victims of

violence. Conduct awareness campaigns on women's legal and Islamic rights.

Offer skills training and employment support for women. Monitor

implementation of protective laws. Engage men and boys as allies in women's

empowerment.

For International Organizations: Support Pakistani government efforts

through technical assistance, capacity building, and funding. Facilitate exchange

of best practices across countries. Support research and data collection on

women's status. Align programs with Sustainable Development Goals

(particularly SDG 5 on gender equality). Respect local religious and cultural

contexts while advocating for universal human rights principles.

150

Al-Qamar,Volume9,Issue1(January-March2026)

For Research Institutions and Universities: Conduct primary research on

women's experiences in diverse Pakistani contexts. Evaluate effectiveness of

specific policy interventions. Develop interdisciplinary programs on gender,

Islam, and development. Publish findings in peer-reviewed journals accessible

to Pakistani audiences. Train the next generation of researchers on gender and

Islam.

References

¹ Qur'an, al-Hujurat 49:13.

² Qur'an, al-Baqarah 2:187.

³ Qur'an, al-Nisa 4:19.

⁴ Al-Jaṣṣāṣ, Abū Bakr. Aḥkām al-Qurʾān. Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-ʿArabi, 1992,

2:245.

⁵ An-Na'im, Abdullahi Ahmed. Islam and the Secular State: Negotiating the Future of

Sharia. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2008, p. 78.

⁶ Iqbal, Nasira. "Women's Rights in Pakistan: Constitutional Promises and Lived Realities."

Lahore University of Management Sciences Law Journal 15, no. 2 (2021): 112.

⁷ Qur'an, al-Nisa 4:32.

⁸ Al-Bukhari, Muhammad ibn Ismaʿil. Sahih al-Bukhari. Damascus: Dar Ibn Kathir, 1414

AH, 3:125.

⁹ Qur'an, al-Baqarah 2:229.

¹⁰ Qur'an, al-Nisa 4:34.

¹¹ Al-Ṭabarī, Muhammad ibn Jarīr. Jāmiʿ al-Bayān fī Taʾwīl al-Qurʾān. Beirut: Muʾassasat

al-Risālah, 2000, 8:156.

¹² Ghamidi, Javed Ahmad. Islam: A Comprehensive Introduction. Lahore: Al-Mawrid,

2019, p. 345.

¹³ Qur'an, al-Raʿd 13:11.

¹⁴ Qur'an, al-Nisa 4:135.

¹⁵ Al-Shāṭibī, Ibrāhīm ibn Mūsā. Al-Muwāfaqāt. Beirut: Dar al-Maʿrifah, 1997, 2:12.

¹⁶ Auda, Jasser. Maqasid al-Shariah as Philosophy of Islamic Law. London: International

Institute of Islamic Thought, 2008, p. 156.

¹⁷ Ibn Mājah, Muhammad ibn Yazīd. Sunan Ibn Mājah. Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-

ʿArabi, 1998, 1:224.

¹⁸ Qur'an, al-Zumar 39:9.

¹⁹ Al-Tirmidhi, Muhammad ibn ʿIsa. Sunan al-Tirmidhi. Beirut: Dar al-Gharb al-Islami,

1998, 4:234.

²⁰ Qur'an, al-Rum 30:21.

²¹ Al-Bukhari, Sahih al-Bukhari, 3:156.

²² Qur'an, al-Shura 42:38.

²³ Qur'an, al-Hujurat 49:13.

²⁴ Zafar, Fariha. "Digital Spaces, Gendered Access: Social Media Use among Young

Pakistani Women." Journal of Digital Culture and Society 8, no. 3 (2023): 234.

²⁵ Qur'an, al-Baqarah 2:286.

²⁶ Qur'an, al-Nisa 4:135.

²⁷ Qur'an, al-Baqarah 2:190.

²⁸ Qur'an, Al-Imran 3:159.

151

Islam and the Changing Role of Women in Contemporary Times: A Special Study...

²⁹ Qur'an, al-Nisa 4:1.

³⁰ Qur'an, Al-Imran 3:110.

³¹ Qur'an, al-Baqarah 2:143.

152