منهج الإمام ابن حزم وابن تيمية في عقيدة الروح القدس ومفهوم النصارى عنه
Ibn Hazm and Ibn Taymiyyah Clarification of the Holy Spirit and its Interpretation in the Christian Belief
Abstract
The writer of this article stated the methodology of Imam Ibn Hazm and Imam Ibn Taymiyyah in their clarification of “The Holy Spirit” The concept of Holy Spirit in the Christian doctrine is one of the integral part that cannot be denied as a result of its great impact in the major part of Trinity that determines the Christian basic belief. "The Father the Son and the Holy Spirit” Both Imam Ibn Hazm and Ibn Taymiyyah analyzed the understanding of this concept and its different interpretation and usages in accordance to references from the Quran and Bible. Both Imams stated the references from Tawrah, the Bible and the Holy Qur’an they declared that, The Holy spirit was used for the other Prophets before Prophet ‘Isa bn Maryam (A.S) Angel Jubreel (A.S) was referred to as “Ruh’ l Qudus” which was not acknowledged by the Christian faith. Some other Prophets like Prophet Adam, Dawud, Daniel, Zakariyyah, Ibraheem , Musa (AS)…and others were also addressed as Ruh, in different verses of Holy Qur’an as well as Tawrah and Gospel. Therefore, Prophet ‘Isa was not the only Prophet that had the title of Holy Spirit. Both Imams proves their researches with evidences from the Tawrah, The Bible, The Holy Qur’an, and Hadeeth which were supported by the early Christian scholars.The methods and methodology of the two great scholars include the dialogues with some sects such as Al-Jahmiyyah and others. Conclusively, both Muslims and the early Christian fathers negates the concept of Holy Spirit when it’s single out for Prophet ‘Isa (A.S).
References
Butrus,1:21
Sifr ‘Aamaal 7 :51-52
Al-‘Imran3:55
Al -Zumar 39:42
Sunnan Abi Dawud, (438) wa rawahu Ahmad,5:299,wa Ibn Haban,(7048)
Al- Baqarah 2:87
- Al- Isiah 25:11 (Salwa min ‘indi – llah)
- Al -Nasraniyah wal –Islam,Muhammad ‘izzat al- Tatawi,:45,46 wa Al Nasraniyah mina Al –Tawheed ila Al Tathleeth:235, wa Al – Masihiyah:Ahmad Shalbi,:156 wa Haqeeqah al – Nasraniyah minal kutub Muqadasa , Saqa, dar Fadheelah, :133
- Ibn Hazm al Andalus, Tahqeeq Ihsaanu Abasi,Ar Radd ‘ala Ibn Nagreelah Al Yahudy warasail ukhra, Jamiah Al- khurtum,matba’ Al-Madani, kunuzul Arab 3,Maktabah daar al – uruba,1380h-1960A.D.
- Al-Zumar 39 :42
- Sunnan Abi Dawud, (438) wa rawahu Ahmad,5:299,wa Ibn Haban,(7048).
- Al- Baqarah 2:87
- Taqiyu deen Abu –l – Abas Ahmad bn Abdul Haleem bn Taymiyah, Majmu’u Fatawa, Majma’ Al –Mulk Fahad 6 (Madina Munawarah,Saudi Arabia) , 2005a1426هـ- 45,4:21
- Al – Jahmiyyah wa qeela Al Jathiyyah:2
- Ibn Taymiyah,Tahqeeq Muhammad Hassan Ismail,tab’ah kamila, Al Jawab Sahih liman badala deen al- Maseeh dar al – kutb al- Misriyyah, al- Maktaba al- ilmiyyah.: 3:281,1:193
- Yahya Ridwan, Al Imam Ibn Hazm al- Andalusiy wa athar al nuz’at al- zhaherah fi ijtihadihi, maktabah al-Rushdi,t.10,1428H -2007 A.D.munashirun:75-76.
- Al-Shurah 42:11
- Fi ((بـ {Haya ‘alima} bi ghaeri waw
- Fi (khai):walaesa yasih.
- Ibn Hazm, Al –Fisal fil milal wal hawwa nihal,Al – Zhairi, dar al – Jael, Beirut - Lubnan 1:113
- Sifr al Takween41:38
- Ibn Taymiyah Al- Jawwab Saheeh 2:37, 4:32
- Ibn Taymiyah, Majmu’u Fatawa 13:108
- Ibn Taymiyah, Majmu’u Fatawa 13:108
- Butrus1:21
- Sifr ‘Aamaal 7 :51-52
- Ar –Ruhul Qudus fi ‘Aqeedah al Nasara:10
- Al-Qasas 28:38
- Sunnan Abi Dawud :4127, Ibn Taymiyah taqiyyu deen Abu –l – Abas Ahmad bn Abdul ‘Aleem Al Harani, d. 728. tahqeeq ‘Abdu Rahman bn Muhammad bn Qasim, majma’-l-Mulk Fahad li taba’ah – l - Mushaf al-Shareef, Al –Madinah Al-Munawarah,1416H-1995A.D, 4:222-223.
- Abu ‘Abdullah -al- Haakim Muhammad bn ‘Abdullah bn Muhammad bn Hamduya bn Naeem bn al- Hakam al –dhabiy al – Tahamaniy al- Nisaburiy- al – al- Ma’ruf bi ibn al- bae’ Al Mustadrak ‘ala saeehaeni,, 405 h.
- Mustafa ‘Abdul Qadir ‘ata, kitabul – Iman baab majeehu Malik –l – mawt ‘nda qabdh al – Ruhu wa dhakara ma yakuun ba’ada dhalik.fil qabri –l- mumin, dar’ al- Ta’rudh” Daar kutub ‘ilmiyah, Beirut- Lubnan,1411H./1990A.Dl1:199
- Muslim,Saheeh Muslim, kitab-al – Jannah wasifat Na’eemuha wa aluha, baab ‘irdh maq’ad al – mayit minal jannah aw al –Naar ‘alaei waithbati ‘adhab al- qabri wa ta’udhu minhu,2872, 4:2.22
- Ar –Ruhul Qudus fi ‘Aqeedah al Nasara:10
- Ar –Ruhul Qudus fi ‘Aqeedah al Nasara:6
- Al-‘Imran3:55
- Al - Zumar 39:42
- Al - Zumar 39:42
- Sifr Takween2:7 (Adam wa Hawwa)
- Luke4:18
- Qamus kitab al Muqadas:392,948
- Muhammad Majdi Marjan, Allah wahid am Thaaluth dar Al – Naadha – Arabiyah Allah wahid am Thaaluth:117 - 120
- Samweel al Awwal:19/23
- Qamus kitab al Muqadas: :392, 948
- Muhammad Majdi Marjan, Allah wahid am Thaaluth: 122 – 124
- Al – Isra17:85
- Majmu’u Fatawa, 4:216
- Majmu’u Fatawa, 13:108
- Al-Jathiyah 45:13
- Sahih al –Bukhari, Baab kitab al – Tawheed:43
- Muhammad Majdi Marjan, Allah wahid am Thaaluth: 122 – 124
- Abu Zahra, Muhadharat fi Nasraniyah 133
- Muhammad ‘izzat al- Tatawi,:Al -Nasraniyah wal –Islam, 45,46 wa Al Nasraniyah mina Al –Tawheed ila Al Tathleeth:235, wa Al – Masihiyah:Ahmad Shalbi,:156 wa Haqeeqah al – Nasraniyah minal kutub Muqadasa , Saqa, dar Fadheelah, :133
- Al Jawab Sahih liman badala deen al- Maseeh dar al – kutb al- Misriyyah, al- Maktaba al- ilmiyyah. 3::36,
- Ahmad Shalbi Al –Masihiyah: al- yahudiyah,Maktabah al Nadha,al-Qairah,t.8,1988A.D:157
- Muhammad Majdi Marjan, Allah wahid am Thaaluth:116
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Copyright (c) 2021 Al-Qamar
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
