Beggary in Law and Islam: A Call to amend the Law in Pakistan
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53762/alqamar.06.03.e08Keywords:
Begging, Vagrancy, Beggary, The Punjab Vagrancy Ordinance, 1958, Beggary in IslamAbstract
Begging in Pakistan is a complex issue with no easy solutions. However, the current approach of criminalizing begging is ineffective and counterproductive. This paper argues that the law on begging in Pakistan needs to be amended to take into account the socio-economic factors contributing to begging and to provide a more compassionate and holistic response to the problem. Poverty, unemployment, and crime rates are prevalent in Pakistan, with begging becoming a necessary option for survival, as five to twenty-five million beggars are found in the country. The laws on begging in Pakistan lack any criteria for distinguishing between professional beggars and those who beg for survival. These laws violate the fundamental rights to life, liberty, equality, and free speech. This paper calls for a deeper understanding of the social and economic factors contributing to begging and the need to amend the law, keeping in due regard to the injunctions of Islam. Rather than punishing beggars, we should focus on addressing the underlying causes of begging and providing beggars with the support they need to live dignified lives. It is high time to create laws that cater to the socio-economic circumstances of our society and to approach this issue with empathy and compassion.
References
A. L. Beier and Ocobock P, Cast Out VAGRANCY AND HOMELESSNESS IN GLOBAL AND HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE (Ohio University Press 2008)
Abdullah AK and Hassan MSB, ‘Socio-Economic Impact of Zakat as a Tool for Sustaining the Welfare of Less-Privileged Muslims.’ <https://uilspace.unilorin.edu.ng/handle/20.500.12484/5994> accessed 30 September 2023
Afroz MS, ‘Begging for Inclusion: State Response to Beggary in India’ [2017] Begging for Inclusion: State Response to Beggary in India <http://scientificresearchjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Social-Science-4_A-656-665-Full-Paper.pdf> accessed 30 September 2023
Ahmad M and others, ‘Zakat as a Social Safety Net: Assessing Its Perception in a Less-Developed Rural District in Pakistan’ (2017) 43 Journal of Social Service Research 369
Ahuja I, ‘Begging for Change: Anti Beggary Laws in India’ (2010) 3 GNLU L. Rev. 35
Anenson TL, ‘Another Casualty of the War: Vagrancy Laws Target the Fourth Amendment’ (14 October 2007) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1021309> accessed 6 July 2023
Ansari AM, Rauf MH and Nazir I, ‘Child Begging in Pakistan: A Case Study of Gujranwala’ (2017) 2 Orient Research Journal of Social Sciences (ORJSS) <https://www.prdb.pk/article/child-begging-in-pakistan-a-case-study-of-gujranwala-9907> accessed 30 September 2023
Azam N, ‘Beggarization: Beggary as an Organized Crime in Pakistan’ (PhD Thesis, University of Kansas 2011) <https://kuscholarworks.ku.edu/handle/1808/9735> accessed 30 September 2023
Baker DJ, ‘A Critical Evaluation of the Historical and Contemporary Justifications for Criminalising Begging’ (2009) 73 The Journal of Criminal Law 212
——, ‘A Critical Evaluation of the Historical and Contemporary Justifications for Criminalizing Begging’ (21 May 2012) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2063740> accessed 6 July 2023
‘Beggary: “A Societal Curse” - Daily Times’ <https://dailytimes.com.pk/993885/beggary-a-societal-curse/> accessed 6 July 2023
‘Begging the Question: Lăcătuş v. Switzerland and the European Court of Human Rights’ Recognition of Begging as a Human Rights Issue’ <https://harvardilj.org/2022/04/begging-the-question-la%cc%86ca%cc%86tus%cc%a7-v-switzerland-and-the-european-court-of-human-rights-recognition-of-begging-as-a-human-rights-issue/> accessed 6 July 2023
Billah MA and Alam MM, ‘Eradication of Street Begging in Bangladesh: In Islamic Perspective’ (2017) 6 Journal of Business and Management 14
Clark G, ‘Pakistan’s Zakat System: A Policy Model for Developing Countries as a Means of Redistributing Income to the Elderly Poor’ (2001) 20 Social Thought 47
Fazal Karim, Judicial Review of Public Actions, vol 2
Ganty S, ‘Da Mihi Elimo Sinam Propter Amorem Dei. The Double-Edged ECtHR Lăcătuş Judgment on Criminalisation of Begging’ (15 November 2021) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3964048> accessed 6 July 2023
Gillin JL, ‘Vagrancy and Begging’ (1929) 35 American Journal of Sociology 424
Goel A, ‘Indian Anti-Beggary Laws and Their Constitutionality Through the Prism of Fundamental Rights with Special Reference to Ram Lakhan V. State’ (30 January 2011) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1748634> accessed 6 July 2023
Goluboff RL, ‘Dispatch from the Supreme Court Archives: Vagrancy, Abortion, and What the Links Between Them Reveal About the History of Fundamental Rights’ (6 July 2009) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1428965> accessed 6 July 2023
Goluboff RL and Sorensen A, ‘United States Vagrancy Laws’, Oxford Research Encyclopedia of American History (2018) <https://oxfordre.com/americanhistory/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780199329175.001.0001/acrefore-9780199329175-e-259> accessed 30 September 2023
‘Hadith - Business Transactions - Bulugh al-Maram - Sunnah.Com - Sayings and Teachings of Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه و سلم)’ <https://sunnah.com/bulugh/7/114> accessed 6 July 2023
Hanafi Y and others, ‘Quranic Forensic on Begging: Formulating Policies and Action Plans to Handle Street Beggars’ (2018) 26 Walisongo: Jurnal Penelitian Sosial Keagamaan 473
‘Harsh Mander & Anr. vs Uoi & Ors. on 8 August, 2018’ <https://indiankanoon.org/doc/117834652/> accessed 6 July 2023
Hartles S, ‘Vagrancy Act 1824: Consign It to History!’ <https://pureportal.strath.ac.uk/en/publications/vagrancy-act-1824-consign-it-to-history> accessed 30 September 2023
Hassan SM and others, ‘“End Up on the Streets”: An Evidence-Based Study on Street-Begging and Poverty in Sialkot, Pakistan’ (2020) 3 Review of Education, Administration & Law 351
Hershkoff H and Cohen AS, ‘Begging to Differ: The First Amendment and the Right to Beg’ (1991) 104 Harvard Law Review 896
Jamil IS, Shah NA and Bashir S, ‘An Analytical Study of the Nature and Issues of Beggars in Karachi’ (2019) 19 Pakistan Journal of Gender Studies 41
‘Keeping the Streets Safe from Free Expression by Richard Moon :: SSRN’ <https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1865931> accessed 6 July 2023
Khan JH, ‘Problem of Beggars: A Case Study’ (2013) 2 International journal of management and social sciences Research 120
——, ‘Socio-Economic Causes of Begging’ (2014) 1 International Research Journal of Human Resources and Social Sciences 37
Khan N and Fahad S, ‘Begging Negative Impact on the World Community’ (1 February 2020) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3530070> accessed 6 July 2023
Kieschnick H, ‘A Cruel and Unusual Way to Regulate the Homeless: Extending the Status Crimes Doctrine to Anti-Homeless Ordinances’ (2018) 70 Stanford Law Review 1569
‘Lăcătuş v. Switzerland (Application No. 14065/15) [19.01.2021]’ (Housing Rights Watch, 22 February 2021) <https://www.housingrightswatch.org/jurisprudence/l%C4%83c%C4%83tu%C5%9F-v-switzerland-application-no-1406515-19012021> accessed 6 July 2023
Laila U and others, ‘The Curse of Vagrancy in Pakistan’ (2020) 6 Journal of Business and Social Review in Emerging Economies 1211
Leckerman J, ‘City of Brotherly Love: Using the Fourteenth Amendment to Strike down an Anti-Homeless Ordinance in Philadelphia’ (2001) 3 U. Pa. J. Const. L. 540
Leigh LH, ‘Vagrancy and Law Reform’ (1977) 40 The Modern Law Review 58
Maeseele T and others, ‘From Vagrancy to Homelessness: The Value of a Welfare Approach to Homelessness’ (2014) 44 The British Journal of Social Work 1717
‘Maharashtra Prevention of Begging Act, 1960’ <http://www.bareactslive.com/MAH/MH191.HTM?AspxAutoDetectCookieSupport> accessed 6 July 2023
Malik M, ‘Street Begging in Delhi: A Study of Anti-Begging Act and Institutional Arrangements for Homeless People’ (20 July 2012) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2148572> accessed 6 July 2023
Maxa CS, ‘Standing While Sleeping: Understanding and Expanding Eight Amendment Protection as a Challenge to the Criminalization of Homelessness’ (2021) 12 Crim. L. Prac. 57
Mirjat AJ, Wassan AA and Shaikh S, ‘Beggary in Hyderabad Division: A Sociological Analysis’ (2017) 51 Journal of Grassroot <https://www.prdb.pk/article/beggary-in-hyderabad-division-a-sociological-analysis-6832> accessed 30 September 2023
Mitchell D, ‘ANTI-HOMELESS LAWS AND PUBLIC SPACE: I. BEGGING AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT’ (1998) 19 Urban Geography 6
——, ‘ANTI-HOMELESS LAWS AND PUBLIC SPACE: II. FURTHER CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES’ (1998) 19 Urban Geography 98
Mohammad F and Anwar M, ‘Prospects of Poverty Eradication Through the Existing" Zakat" System in Pakistan [with Comments]’ (1991) 30 The Pakistan Development Review 1119
Muhasim A and others, ‘EFFECTIVENESS OF ZAKAT REGULATIONS TO REDUCE POVERTY IN INDONESIA’ <https://www.xisdxjxsu.asia/V19I05-32.pdf> accessed 30 September 2023
Mukherjee D, ‘Laws For Beggars, Justice for Whom: A Critical Review of the Bombay Prevention of Begging Act 1959’ (2008) 12 The International Journal of Human Rights 279
Ng P, ‘Repealing the Vagrancy Act 1824’ (2021) Series 2 Vol. 3 Amicus Curiae 131
Ortiz J, Dick M and Rankin S, ‘The Wrong Side of History: A Comparison of Modern and Historical Criminalization Laws’ (4 May 2015) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2602533> accessed 6 July 2023
Participation E, ‘Vagrancy Act 1824’ <https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Geo4/5/83> accessed 30 September 2023
Ramanathan U, ‘Ostensible Poverty, Beggary and the Law’ [2008] Economic and Political Weekly 33
Rankin S, ‘Punishing Homelessness’ (1 January 2019) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3410627> accessed 6 July 2023
——, ‘Begging for Change: Begging Restrictions Throughout Washington’ (3 May 2018) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3173191> accessed 6 July 2023
Rasool F and Kausar R, ‘Psychosocial Causes of Beggary: Modes and Effects of Beggary’ (2022) 16 FWU Journal of Social Sciences 28
‘Repeal of the Vagrancy Act 1824: Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 Factsheet’ (GOV.UK) <https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-bill-2021-factsheets/repeal-of-the-vagrancy-act-1824-police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-act-2022-factsheet> accessed 30 September 2023
‘Report on Vagrancy and Related Offences 4’ <https://www.lawreform.ie/_fileupload/reports/rvagrancy.htm> accessed 6 July 2023
Shaikh SA, ‘Welfare Potential of Zakat: An Attempt to Estimate Economy Wide Zakat Collection in Pakistan’ [2015] The Pakistan Development Review 1011
Sherry AH, ‘Vagrants, Rogues and Vagabonds. Old Concepts in Need of Revision’ (1960) 48 California Law Review 557
Suhaib AQ, ‘Contribution of Zakat in the Social Development of Pakistan’ (2009) 29 Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences 313
Sultan H, Khawaja AO and Ishaq G, ‘Exploitation of Teenage Beggars in Lahore, Pakistan’ (2022) 3 Human Nature Journal of Social Sciences 251
‘THE [PUNJAB] VAGRANCY ORDINANCE, 1958’ <http://punjablaws.gov.pk/laws/94.html> accessed 6 July 2023
Thomas BC, ‘Examining a Beggar’s First Amendment Right to Beg in an Era of Anti-Begging Ordinances: The Presence and Persistence Test’ (2000) 26 U. Dayton L. Rev. 155
Victor D, ‘Begging and Almsgiving in Nigeria: The Islamic Perspective’
VijaY UP, ‘“The Destitutes and Their Problems” (A Study with Special Reference to the Destitute Depending on the Begging from the Worshipers Near the Various Temples of the City of Bangalore)’ (20 September 2011) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2423506> accessed 6 July 2023
Wassan AA and Khuro S, ‘Beggary in District Sanghar: A Sociological Analysis of Shahdadpur, Tandoadam and Sinjhoro Subdivisions’ (2011) 5 New Horizons 28
‘Zakat (Kitab Al-Zakat) - Sunnah.Com - Sayings and Teachings of Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه و سلم)’ <https://sunnah.com/abudawud/9> accessed 6 July 2023
Zia A and Hussain B, ‘The Problem of Beggary in Pakistan: An Analysis in the Light of Islamic Teachings.’ (2022) 11 Al Basirah <https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&profile=ehost&scope=site&authtype=crawler&jrnl=22224548&AN=162183466&h=WnPoLVUI%2BHV9Pq4A7I6XhK51vg%2BZQysMzBPN5C0cYMDoZq41y0pD31TKfqpurpdrBXXor7x%2B2BZZnicXx59pxg%3D%3D&crl=c> accessed 30 September 2023
Abdul Wahab and others v HBL and others 2013 SCMR 1383 (Supreme Court of Pakistan)
Ahmad Omar Sheikh and 3 Others v Government of Sindh 2022 YLR 217 (Lahore High Court)
Badshah v Sou Urmila Badshah Godse & anr 2014 SCC 188 (Supreme Court of India)
Baz Muhammad Kakar v Federation of Pakistan PLD 2012 SC 870 (Supreme Court of Pakistan)
‘Harsh Mander & Anr v Uoi & Ors (Delhi High Court)
Indian Express Newspapers (Bombay) (P) Ltd v Union of India 1985 SCC 641 (Supreme Court of India)
Khawaja Salman Rafique v National Accountability Bureau PLD 2020 SC 456 (Supreme Court of Pakistan)
Ms Shehla Zia’s case PLD 1994 SC 693 (Supreme Court of Pakistan)
Pir Imran Sajid and others v Managing Director/General Manager (Manager Finance) Telephone Industries of Pakistan and others 2015 SCMR 1257 (Supreme Court of Pakistan)
Sh Riaz ul Haq v Federation of Pakistan through ministry of law PLD 2013 SC 501 (Supreme Court of Pakistan)
Shayaro Bano v Union of India 2017 SCC 1 (Supreme Court of India)
Tariq Shah v Provincial Police Officer Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Peshawar 2018 PCrLJ 947 (Lahore High Court)
Texas v Johnson 491 U.S. 397, 414 (1989)
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Copyright (c) 2023 Al-Qamar
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
